Some say Reese's peanut butter PUMPKINS 🎃 are better than all the other Reese's cups. I mean, the cute shape gives it instant brownie points🤩 Well we have something that just might one up the iconic Reese's peanut butter pumpkins...and the trick to the magic? Joolies date syrup! And using minimal ingredients that supersede the instant refined sugar gratification. With these Copycat Reese's Peanut Butter Pumpkins you get that indulgent satisfaction without the sugar crash of traditional candy. Let's get into this date recipe 😎
All you need are five simple ingredients to create this nostalgic candy into a better-for-you version that is vegan, gluten-free, and refined sugar-free. They're super easy to whip up and make for a great treat to keep on hand when that craving hits. Just pop em in an air-tight bag/container and store in the freezer.
Tips for homemade Reese's Pumpkins
- Add more coconut flour as needed. Depending on what kind of peanut (or nut) butter you use, the filling may be runnier and more difficult to mold so add more coconut flour as needed--Keep in mind a little goes a long way😊 We recommend adding in 1/2 tbsp increments.
- Coat the sides of the mold really good. To make sure you get a pretty and even chocolate coating, be sure the sides get covered before plopping in the pb filling. If they don't you'll have more fo a pb pumpkin sandwich.
- Add some spice/toppings! Take things up a notch and add a little bit of spice, flakey sea salt, or sprinkles!
- Store in the freezer. For 💯 freshness, store the peanut butter pumpkins in an air-tight container in the freezer. Plus, they will best maintain their cute pumpkin shape that way.
Ingredients you'll need:
- Peanut Butter
- What's a Reese's without peanut butter? We recommend using a creamy PB that has no added oils or sugars in it like 365 brand or Wild Friends. If you have a peanut allergy, not to fret! You can easily swap the PB for an almond, cashew, or one of our favorite nut-free options: Oat Haus granola butter😍
- Joolies Medjool Date Syrup
- Instead of all that yucky sugar and preservatives in the traditional Reese's, this natural sweetener with benefits is the perfect swap. Made with only one ingredient: organic medjool dates. You still maintain all the nutrient and health benefits of a medjool date in the syrup form! Woohoo!
- Coconut flour
- This helps to thicken the batter to achieve that perfect peanut butter filling texture. You can swap for almond flour, but you might need to add a bit more to bind everything up. Coconut flour naturally absorbs a ton of liquid, which is why you need so little!
- Dark Chocolate Chips
- Coconut Oil
- Adding a little bit of this into our melted chocolate helps to thin out the chocolate to make pouring/dipping easier and allows it to harden faster when placed in the freezer! Plus coconut oil also contains healthy fatty acids called MCTs which promote brain function.
- Peanut Butter
More Better-for-you Candy Recipes You'll Love:
- Homemade Vegan Almond Joys
- Pumpkin Spice Peanut Butter Cups
- Paleo Twix Bars
- Vegan Cookie Dough Bites
- Peanut Butter Buckeyes